Santa Monica City Prosecutors Obtain a Trio of Wins in Short-Term Vacation Rental Enforcement Cases
March 7, 2019
SANTA MONICA, Calif. — In the last month, the Santa Monica City Attorney’s Office has obtained two convictions and an appellate win all involving enforcement of the City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance. All three case were investigated by the City’s Vacation Rental Enforcement Task Force, a unit of the City’s Code Enforcement Division trained to target illegal vacation rental businesses operating in Santa Monica.
“The City of Santa Monica has consistently dedicated policies and resources toward producing, protecting, and preserving housing in our community,” said Chief Deputy City Attorney Yibin Shen. “These convictions and the appellate win represent just outcomes and further affirms these important legislative goals.”
On February 19, 2019, in City of Santa Monica v. Diana Hayek, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court dismissed Defendant Hayek’s appeal and affirmed eleven counts of short-term rental violations against Hayek for illegally advertising and operating a short-term vacation rental business in the City of Santa Monica. The trial court decision in this case made clear that the City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance is a valid exercise of the City’s police powers and not preempted by the California Coastal Act. The trial court further held that the Home-Sharing Ordinance “does not require a costal development permit and the [Coastal] Commission’s authority does not extent to approving or rejecting general laws adopted by cities.”
On February 26, 2019, in People v. Ryan Anderson, Defendant Anderson was convicted of operating an illegal short-term rental business and failing to comply with City citations. Anderson was placed on three years of probation and ordered to:
- Pay thousands in criminal fines with statutory penalties and assessments.
- Pay restitution to the City of Santa Monica in the amount of $854.64 in investigative costs.
- Pay $10,000 in administrative citation penalties.
- Comply with all laws, including the City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance’s prohibition against hosting, facilitating, aiding, or advertising a vacation rental in the City.
On March 5, 2019, in People v. Globe Homes, Ari Can Eryorulmaz, and Sebastian Pieter Dekleer, the Defendants were convicted of violations of the City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance. The Defendants were placed on three years of probation or probationary diversion with the following conditions:
- Defendants Eryorulmaz and Dekleer must each perform twenty days of community service.
- Defendant Globe Homes must pay over ten thousand dollars in criminal fines with statutory penalties and assessments.
- The three Defendants must pay restitution to the City of Santa Monica in the amount of $1,025.20 in investigative costs.
- The three Defendants must comply with all laws, including the City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance’s prohibition against hosting, facilitating, aiding, or advertising a vacation rental in the City.
These three cases have much in common. Each of the Defendants operated illegal vacation rental businesses in the City of Santa Monica that unlawfully removed numerous residential housing units from the permanent housing market. The convictions and appellate win in these cases will result in the return of these residential housing units back to the permanent housing market.
“These are outstanding results and testaments to the exceptional team work between the Code Enforcement Division and the City Attorney’s Office,” said Code Enforcement Manager Sharon Guidry. “My team of dedicated Code Enforcement Officers are committed to enforcing this important legislation and ensuring that Santa Monica remains a place that people from all income levels and backgrounds can call home.”
Home-Sharing in Santa Monica
After maintaining a multi-decade prohibition against short-term rentals in residential districts, in 2015, the City eased this prohibition by authorizing a form of short-term rentals known as Home-Sharing, wherein a resident is free to host visitors for compensation for a period of less than 31 days, as long as the resident and visitor are both present in the home. Un-hosted short-term rentals of residential housing, known as Vacation Rentals, remain unlawful in Santa Monica. This landmark legislation struck an important balance by enabling current and prospective residents to supplement income through home-sharing to meet increased rents and housing prices, while ensuring that Santa Monica’s housing units, and particularly affordable units, would not be surreptitiously or openly converted into de facto hotels.
For more information on the City’s Home-Sharing Ordinance or to apply for a Home-Sharing License, visit www.smgov.net/homeshare.
To report an illegal vacation rental business, contact Code Enforcement at (310) 458-4984.